How to Excel as a General Evaluator at Toastmasters: Tips and a Live Breakdown

By Wade Paterson

The General Evaluator role is widely considered one of the most challenging assignments you can take on at a Toastmasters meeting. You're responsible for evaluating nearly every role in the room — all while staying within a tight time limit. It's demanding, it requires razor-sharp attention, and it can feel overwhelming if you're not prepared. But with the right approach, you can not only handle the role with confidence but deliver genuine value to every member in the room. Here's what I've learned from taking on this role myself, including a candid self-critique of my own live General Evaluation.

What Exactly Does a General Evaluator Do?

The General Evaluator is the person who evaluates every role that hasn't already received an evaluation during the meeting. Think about how many roles that covers:

Ironically, the General Evaluator is the only role that doesn't receive an evaluation during the meeting. You're giving feedback to a large number of people, which means you need to be alert, engaged, and taking notes from the very first word spoken until the very last.

Preparation Starts with Your Notepad

If there's one thing I cannot stress enough, it's the importance of thorough note-taking. When I delivered my live General Evaluation, my sheet of paper was completely full by the end of the meeting. Every observation, every standout moment, every piece of constructive feedback — it all went onto that page.

But here's the key: keep your notes concise. Write keywords, not full sentences. If you're writing detailed paragraphs during the meeting, you'll struggle to scan your notes quickly while standing in front of an audience. A simple phrase like "Joe — vocal variety" is enough to jog your memory about everything you observed. If you have a suggestion for improvement, just write "gift" beside the keyword. This shorthand system lets you glance down, recall the thought, and articulate it naturally without losing your connection with the audience.

Breaking Down My Live General Evaluation

To give you a practical sense of how this role works, let me walk you through my own General Evaluation and the lessons I drew from watching it back.

The Introduction: Set the Stage Quickly

I opened with the standard formalities — "Thank you, Mr. Toastmaster, fellow Toastmasters, and our welcome guests" — and then immediately explained what the General Evaluator role is. In other speaking roles, you might open with a hook to grab attention, and doing so here would certainly be an elite move. However, I find that the General Evaluator's primary mission is to deliver as much feedback as possible within a very limited window. Spending time on a creative hook can eat into your precious minutes.

One thing I was glad I did: explaining the General Evaluator role for the audience. It's easy to skip this when you're eager to dive into your notes, but it's especially important when guests are present. They need context to understand what's happening.

Evaluating the Toastmaster and Other Key Roles

Our club president, Dan, served as Toastmaster that evening, and there was plenty to commend. I highlighted his smooth transitions, the energy he brought to the meeting's opening, and a subtle but important detail: he introduced speakers by their first and last names. He also handled distractions gracefully, speaking above side chatter without losing composure — a skill that deserves recognition.

For Fahad, who delivered the toast, I praised his enthusiasm and eye contact but offered a specific piece of constructive feedback I call "the Invisible Table." This is one of the most common habits I see in Toastmasters: speakers hold their hands at a 90-degree angle in front of their body and never let them drop. The fix is simple — let your hands fall naturally to your sides and bring them up only for emphasis. It's a small adjustment that dramatically improves your stage presence.

Use Third Person — Always

One principle I follow religiously during evaluations is staying in the third person. Even when I'm looking directly at Fahad, I say "Fahad did this well" rather than "You did this well." The reason is powerful: when you address someone as "you," the feedback feels like a private conversation. When you use their name, everyone in the room absorbs the lesson. The evaluation becomes a gift to the entire club, not just one individual.

Highlight Specific Moments with Vivid Detail

When evaluating Amit's Humorist and Inspirational role, I didn't just say he had great body language. I referenced the exact words he said — "in a galaxy far away" — and described how he opened his arms wide to let the audience feel the moment. This specificity is a powerful technique. When you note someone's actual words alongside their body language in your notes, it helps the audience recall the precise moment and reinforces why it was effective.

Give Everyone Their Moment

One of the biggest pitfalls I see General Evaluators fall into is spending too much time on the first few roles. They'll give thorough feedback to the Toastmaster and the toast speaker, then see the red light flash and realize they still have five more people to cover. Suddenly, they're rushing and panicking.

I'll be honest — I fell into this trap myself. My evaluation ran about five minutes and fifty seconds, roughly fifty seconds over the typical three-to-five-minute window. The lesson? Keep a brisk, steady pace throughout. Every person who contributed to the meeting deserves acknowledgement. If you linger too long on early roles, you're shortchanging the people who came later.

Be Ready to Adapt

Here's a scenario I've witnessed many times: the Toastmaster lets the agenda run long, and then at the very end says, "Can you please give a concise version of your General Evaluation?" It's not entirely fair to the General Evaluator, who has been diligently taking notes and preparing throughout the entire meeting, but it happens.

If you find yourself with only two minutes instead of five, you need to adapt on the fly. Perhaps you planned to mention two things for every role — scale it back to one. The ability to condense your feedback without losing its substance is a skill that comes with practice, but simply being aware that this might happen will keep you from being caught off guard.

Lessons from My Own Self-Critique

Watching my evaluation back, I noticed several areas where I could improve:

Key Tips for Your Next General Evaluation

It's a Challenge Worth Taking On

The General Evaluator role exists for one purpose: to help the members of your club grow as speakers and leaders by giving them genuine, thoughtful feedback. It's demanding, yes. It requires sustained concentration, rapid note-taking, and the ability to deliver organised commentary under time pressure. But it's also one of the most rewarding roles you can volunteer for, because you're actively contributing to every person's speaking journey in a single meeting. Whether you're a seasoned Toastmaster or a brand-new member, I encourage you to sign up for this role. Stay alert, take great notes, keep your pace steady, and trust that your observations have real value. You'll improve every time you do it — and your clubmates will thank you for it.

Want to become a more confident speaker?

Get my free guide — 10 Public Speaking Mistakes and How to Fix Them

Get the Free Guide